Muscle – STATE OF SPEED https://stateofspeed.com ALL THINGS PERFORMANCE AND SPEED, AND THE CULTURE THAT DRIVES IT Tue, 14 May 2024 22:46:51 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.6.2 https://stateofspeed.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/Shift-Knob-RGB.png Muscle – STATE OF SPEED https://stateofspeed.com 32 32 Classic Muscle Flexing at SEMA https://stateofspeed.com/2021/11/04/sema-2021-muscle/ https://stateofspeed.com/2021/11/04/sema-2021-muscle/#comments Thu, 04 Nov 2021 20:24:23 +0000 http://54.201.197.135/?p=28824

Muscle cars and Hot Rods have been the backbone of SEMA, lets take a peek at what V8s are rumbling around SEMA!Read More →

The post Classic Muscle Flexing at SEMA appeared first on STATE OF SPEED.

]]>

Classic V8 Muscle Cars

Clean and Low Restomods at SEMA 2021

Muscle cars and Hot Rods have been the backbone of SEMA since the beginning. Year after year not only do they show up, they are some of the most immaculate and classiest builds the 2021 SEMA Show has to offer. As we were perusing the show floor, we happened to see some beautiful examples. Lets take a peek at what V8s are rumbling around SEMA. (none probably, we’d be surprised if anything actually ran at SEMA)

Right off the bat are a couple of Chevelles so clean and modded you can barely recognize them!

Strange Motion Blue Chevelle at SEMA 2021
Vehicle: Chevrolet Chevelle

 

Blue Chevelle at SEMA 2021
Vehicle Chevrolet Chevelle

 

Next we have this gorgeous blue Fastback Mustang and this slick Camaro. Both retain that classic styling but have opted for much more modern trim pieces, bringing these old geezers into the 21st Century.

Blue Fastback Mustang at SEMA 2021
Vehicle: Fastback Mustang

 

Green Chevrolet Camaro at SEMA 2021
Vehicle: Green Chevrolet Camaro
Booth: Meguiar’s

Next up we have a couple of Old Chevy Trucks done in two completely different finishes. One With a nice slick green paint job that highlights those 50s body lines.

Green Chevy Cameo Carrier at SEMA 2021
Vehicle: Chevrolet Cameo Carrier

The other finished in a patina paint so strong it looks like it was pulled out of a lake! But there probably isn’t a spec of rust on this Apache.

Update: The owner of the build reached out to us and confirmed that this Apache is indeed 100% real patina.

“My Apache literally burned to the ground in the 2018 NorCal Paradise Fire and was on live tv doing so […] No rattle can patina, pure fire, then rain.  […] It was important for me to build this ride so people wouldn’t forget the devastation of that fire and when they see the truck, they know something survived.”Jason Fonte

ITM TPMS Patina Chevrolet Apache Lowered Truck
Vehicle: Chevrolet Apache
Booth: Cub Autoparts

The post Classic Muscle Flexing at SEMA appeared first on STATE OF SPEED.

]]>
https://stateofspeed.com/2021/11/04/sema-2021-muscle/feed/ 1
You Bought a New Track Car – Now What? https://stateofspeed.com/2021/10/01/you-bought-a-new-track-car-now-what/ https://stateofspeed.com/2021/10/01/you-bought-a-new-track-car-now-what/#respond Fri, 01 Oct 2021 13:12:05 +0000 http://54.201.197.135/?p=28094

The days of picking up an affordable, unmolested 240sx are long gone, leaving us to wonder what might be the next platform to take its place. Read More →

The post You Bought a New Track Car – Now What? appeared first on STATE OF SPEED.

]]>

You Bought A New Track Car – Now What?

Essentials for Hot Laps on a 5k Budget

So you’ve taken the plunge and bought yourself a dedicated track car. You did your research, found what you were looking for in sound mechanical condition and not already so far from stock that you’d have to rip everything out before doing it the way it should have been done in the first place, and you’re eager to get it prepped and put some laps on it. But you’re not made of money, and your meme stocks only got you into low earth orbit instead of to the moon, so you have a $5,000 budget for everything you’re going to need. 

Some hard choices will have to be made, because every dollar spent in one area means a dollar less to spend somewhere else. Here’s how we would allocate those 50 Benjamins most effectively – while your priorities are going to vary from ours, having a plan is the difference between a car on the track and yard art on jackstands for another year because you ran out of money and motivation.

Helmet – $350 ($4,650 Remaining)

red, black , and white helmet sitting on top of a car at a track day event

Yes, we know you already have a helmet you bought off Craigslist. Yes, we know you are the one driver who will never, ever crash. This is still non-negotiable. Every reputable track day event organizer will insist on an ‘in-date’ skid lid that meets an accepted testing standard. Most often this is Snell SA or its equivalent – some sanctions will accept a Snell M-rated helmet, but the DOT-only models are almost always not considered good enough, for a reason.

White Porsche 911 races through a track

Helmets designed to meet the SA and similar ratings have features that make them better suited for automotive use, where sharp impacts with objects that can penetrate the shell are more likely than the types of forces involved in motorcycle crashes, and they’ll have a fire-resistant liner. The “in-date” part is important too; the impact-absorbing liner has a finite lifespan, which gets shorter the more it is exposed to temperature extremes or solvent and gasoline fumes. 

several different open-face helmets on a helmet rack

While it’s possible to get an open-face helmet that carries a SA2020 tag for as little as $160, we recommend a full-face model, and as the list price goes up you’ll also get better fit and finish and improved comfort, which is important when you’re trying to concentrate on-track. Throw in another $40 or so for a fire resistant head sock (also good for comfort, as well as keeping the liner of the helmet cleaner) and $350 is a reasonable starting point for this critically important item.

Tires/Wheels – $2000 ($2650 Remaining)

red honda civic type r with milestar tires wrapped around motegi wheels
Vehicle: Honda Civic Type R
Tires: Milestar MS932XP+ – 265/35ZR18

We’re assuming that if you’re limited to a $5k overall budget for track car upgrades, you’re probably not going to trailer to and from events. We’re also going to assume that you will want a separate set of wheels and tires so that you’re not burning through expensive high-performance tires daily driving on them (though mad props to you if you are hardcore like that – we’ve been there ourselves). Like everything else on this list, wheels aren’t an area where you want to cut corners, but it’s entirely possible to get into a set of four new, quality wheels from a reputable manufacturer for around a grand. For that price, you are looking at cast rather than forged wheels, so the tradeoff is slightly higher weight for a lower price, as well as not being as forgiving or repairable when tweaked during inevitable encounters with debris or curbs.

Like everything else on this list, wheels aren’t an area where you want to cut corners, but it’s entirely possible to get into a set of four new, quality wheels from a reputable manufacturer for around a grand…

 

Blue BMW M3 E46 on a rainy track with spare tires and wheels

Tires are consumables, and depending on how hard you run them and what your level of compromise is between grip and longevity, these may have to be replaced several times a season. Fortunately, it’s often possible to find a well-heeled fellow enthusiast who always has used tires that have ‘gone off’ for full-boogie competition purposes but still have plenty of laps left in them for less serious use, so we’re compromising and putting a cost of $250 a corner out there to give some wiggle room for that initial set. Like always, your experience may vary, and cars with uncommon fitments or really big meat will tend toward the more pricey end of the spectrum. 

Brake Upgrades – $1250 ($1400)

red honda civic type r with milestar tires wrapped around motegi wheels and using Brembo brakes
Vehicle: Honda Civic Type R
Tires: Milestar MS932XP+ – 265/35ZR18

Here’s another area where there is a wide range of possibilities – if your track car has decent stock brakes, all that may be necessary for anything less than full competition use might be a change to a different brake compound, braided stainless flex lines, new rotors, and a fluid flush and bleed. On the other hand, most cars of interest to the track day crowd have a lot of bolt-on options at surprisingly reasonable prices. If you don’t go totally nuts, our budget should at least cover a front caliper upgrade in addition to the other things mentioned above, plus a spare set of pads to be bedded in and brought with you if you’ve chosen a soft-but-grippy compound and a tight course to run on for a mid-day swap.

if your track car has decent stock brakes, all that may be necessary for anything less than full competition use might be a change to a different brake compound, braided stainless flex lines, new rotors, and a fluid flush and bleed…

 

Green and White porsche 911 on jack stands without wheels in a garage at a track

Suspension upgrades – $1400

bilstein coilovers

We’re going to take the last of our remaining budget and allocate it toward suspension. On the less expensive end of the scale, a complete, properly engineered and matched set of quality replacement springs, dampers, anti-roll bars, and polyurethane bushings can set you back as little as $750, while the sky is the limit for a complete competition-spec coilover conversion with multi-way adjustable dampers. We’re splitting the difference here, but odds are you will come in either substantially above or below our average estimated price. Depending on what kind of tracks you prefer, you may prioritize suspension above brakes, or the other way around, and adjust your spending on these last two categories accordingly.

blue mitsubishi lancer evolution on milestar MS932 Sport tires and brembo brakes
Vehicle: Mitsubishi Lancer Evolution
Tires: Milestar MS932 Sport – 235/45R17

One thing you absolutely do not want to do under any circumstances is to cheap out here; there are a lot of janky ‘lowering kits’ and coilover conversion setups with suspiciously low price tags and brand names you have never heard of, but spending any money on components of dubious quality and unclear origin can only lead to disaster. 

That Money Went Fast…

yellow porsche 911 GT2 speeding through a track on a track day

 

blue, yellow, purple, and white M series BMWs getting ready to race around a track

 

various porsches race around a track

As you can see, it doesn’t take a whole lot to blow through $5k getting your new toy set up properly, but going into it with clear expectations for the cost and effort involved can keep your dreams from dying before you ever get to the track. Keep in mind that this is just a start, and in order to keep your racing fun sustainable, it’s a good idea to set aside money for every event you attend in some place where you won’t spend it, to be used for future consumables like tires, brakes, and maintenance items. Budgeting is never fun, but it makes the fun stuff possible, and helps you to drive more and dream less. 

The post You Bought a New Track Car – Now What? appeared first on STATE OF SPEED.

]]>
https://stateofspeed.com/2021/10/01/you-bought-a-new-track-car-now-what/feed/ 0
Hot Swaps https://stateofspeed.com/2021/09/29/hot-swaps/ https://stateofspeed.com/2021/09/29/hot-swaps/#respond Wed, 29 Sep 2021 13:07:45 +0000 http://54.201.197.135/?p=28087

Let’s look at some of the most common types of chassis and engine swap combinations and the reasons behind them.Read More →

The post Hot Swaps appeared first on STATE OF SPEED.

]]>

Hot Swaps

Engine And Chassis Combos Limited Only By Imagination

Engine swaps might seem like a recent thing, but OG hot rodders did it back in the 1950s, putting the then-new small block Chevy V8 into Ford Model T chassis, and when Cadillac created a long-stroke 500ci version of their corporate big block in 1970, wrecked Eldorados became a prime target for drag racers looking for as many cubes as they could get. Today, despite tightening regulations that threaten to make any kind of automotive modification illegal, let alone a complete motor swap, mixing and matching cars and drivetrains has never been more popular. Let’s look at some of the most common types of hybrid chassis and engine combinations (and we mean that in the cool way, not the electric motor ‘hybrid’ sense) and the reasons behind them.

Red honda s2000 with an Chevy LS2 crate engine swap
Vehicle: Honda S2000 with an LS Swap

 

All In The Family

Highly Modified Honda B-Series Engine
Highly Modified Honda B-Series Engine

In terms of sheer numbers of completed swaps, updating (or backdating, in some cases) a particular car with an engine from the same manufacturer takes the top position. In the import and sport compact world, the most common swaps involve upgrading Hondas with more powerful engines – the trend began with taking lightweight Civic or CRX shells originally equipped with fuel-sipping but low-output D-series four cylinder engines and replacing them with more powerful B-series engines from models higher up on the price and performance ladder. With the introduction of the even more powerful and versatile K-series, those became the donor engines of choice, despite being somewhat more complicated to swap due to the necessity of changing transmissions as well. The extra effort is worth it, though; 200 horsepower or more from a completely stock engine in a late-90’s Civic that tips the scales at under 2,400 pounds makes for very entertaining performance at an affordable price.

In terms of sheer numbers of completed swaps, updating (or backdating, in some cases) a particular car with an engine from the same manufacturer takes the top position…

modified Honda B series engine
Modified Honda B-Series Engine

Honda engine swaps have become so popular that you can find ready-made components like engine and transmission mounts, headers, and ECU adapters for pretty much any reasonable (and more than a few unreasonable) combination of engine and chassis. With the trailblazing handled, potential compatibility issues have all been sorted out by somebody somewhere. It just takes a bit of research to come up with a proven recipe to follow, and entire books have been written on the subject covering every last detail.

Blue nissan 240sx with a Nissan SR series engine swap
Vehicle: Nissan 240SX S13
Tires: Milestar MS932 Sport – 235/40R18
Blue nissan 240sx with a Nissan SR series engine swap
Vehicle: Nissan 240SX S13
Tires: Milestar MS932 Sport – 235/40R18

Another common form of swap involves putting an engine not available in the US market into a chassis that was sold here, with the first example that comes to mind being the Nissan 240SX. Known in Japan as the 180SX and Silvia, when the company brought this fun little RWD coupe to America, they decided to replace the JDM CA and SR series turbocharged engines with KA series naturally aspirated ones. This decision was likely based on the fact that the KA engines were already “federalized” for US emissions regulations and would be less expensive than bringing in a new powerplant without an existing approval. Though well-suited for mainstream buyers, since these engines had previously been used in Nissan’s Hardbody line, they were derided by some as ‘truck engines’ unworthy of the car’s sporty image.

Highly modified nissan KA series engine
Highly Modified Nissan KA-Series Engine
Highly Modified Nissan KA-Series Engine in a Nissan Bluebird
Vehicle: Nissan Bluebird with a Highly Modified Nissan KA-Series Engine

Of course, enthusiasts care not for things such as EPA regulations, and many CA and SR engines got strapped to pallets in Japanese wrecking yards and shipped to the west coast to be reunited with S13 and S14 240SX models here. Some particularly ambitious souls went as far as to cram RB26DETT twin turbo inline sixes from the JDM Skyline GT-R (among other applications) into that chassis as well.

Nissan Skyline GT-R RB26DETT twin turbo inline six engine inside a Nissan/Datsun 240Z
Vehicle: Nissan/Datsun 240Z with a Skyline GT-R RB26DETT Twin Turbo Inline Six Engine

Speaking of legendary Japanese turbo sixes, let’s not forget the Toyota 2JZ-GTE. This engine powered a whole generation of the company’s flagship performance models, but only came to US showrooms in the Mark IV Supra Turbo. This engine has found its way into a number of different swaps, including both Lexus IS300/GS300/SC300 models as a replacement for its naturally-aspirated sibling, the 2JZ-GE, as well as other non-Toyotas with engine bays long enough to accommodate the sizeable inline six. 

Red Toyota Supra with a highly modified 2JZ-GTE Engine
Vehicle: Toyota Supra with a Highly Modified 2JZ-GTE Engine

Could Have Had a V8

Chevy LS1 Crate Engine inside a Orange '55 Chevrolet Nomad
Vehicle: 1955 Chevy Nomad with an LS1 Crate Engine
Tires: Milestar MS932 Sport – 205/50R17 Front – 235/60R17 Rear
Chevy LS1 Crate Engine inside a Orange '55 Chevrolet Nomad
Vehicle: 1955 Chevy Nomad with an LS1 Crate Engine
Tires: Milestar MS932 Sport – 205/50R17 Front – 235/60R17 Rear

Don’t think this is just limited to import brands, either. When Ford ended production of their classic pushrod 5.0 liter V8 engine in the mid-90s and replaced it with the high-tech overhead cam Modular family, it was only a matter of time before those engines started to find their way into Fox-body Mustangs and even classics. One of the disadvantages of overhead cam cylinder heads in a V-configuration engine layout is that compared to pushrod designs of similar displacement, they inevitably end up larger in width and height. Adding cams and timing gear to the top of the cylinders makes them inherently taller than engines that simply have to accommodate rocker arms beneath the valve covers. In a bit of irony, older muscle cars with their large engine bays have more room to accept Modular V8 swaps, making them somewhat easier to work on than modern factory Fords with cramped under-hood layouts. 

Yellow Chevy C-10 Stepside drag racer with an LS Engine swap
Vehicle: Chevy C-10 Stepside with an LS Engine

While Ford was breaking ties with their previous engine architecture, GM took a less radical path, introducing the first LS-series engines. These successors to the original small-block Chevy V8 and its follow-on “Gen II” LT replacements are in many ways a “what might have been” look at the direction Ford could have taken with their own small-block pushrod architecture. Though the Gen II engines had a lot of problems including a notoriously unreliable optical ignition pickup and were widely panned by gearheads, the Gen III/IV LS family turned out to be a huge success.

Lightweight, powerful, durable, plentiful, and cheap, they quickly replaced the venerable SBC as the engine of choice for GM swaps. Like the aforementioned Honda engines, a huge aftermarket has developed to make putting an LS into an older car easy, right down to complete kits that handle ignition and carburetion should you choose to go old-school and ‘downgrade’ from EFI. Another factor that led to their popularity was that they were manufactured in both iron and aluminum block form, so that those in search of an inexpensive and bomb-proof bottom end could simply grab a low-compression iron block truck motor from the local pick-a-part and feed it a decent amount of boost or nitrous without a lot of drama.

 

Chevy LS Engine inside a chevrolet C-10 pick up truck Bronze '72 C10 Hills Rod & Custom - 255/45R20 - 275/40R20 MS932XP+/
Vehicle: 1972 Chevy C-10 Restomod with and LS Engine
Tires: Milestar MS932XP+ 255/45R20 – 275/40R20
Chevy LS Engine inside a chevrolet C-10 pick up truck Bronze '72 C10 Hills Rod & Custom - 255/45R20 - 275/40R20 MS932XP+/
Vehicle: 1972 Chevy C-10 Restomod with and LS Engine
Tires: Milestar MS932XP+ 255/45R20 – 275/40R20

Cross Breeding

Yellow Toyota Sprinter with a Corvette LS6 Engine
Vehicle: Toyota Sprinter with an LS6 Engine from a Corvette

While mixing and matching engines and chassis from the same manufacturer often makes things somewhat easier because of shared mechanical and electronic components, taking an engine from one maker and stuffing it into another company’s car has been popular forever as well. As we mentioned before, early hot rodders who started out by putting Ford Flathead V8 engines into Model Ts embraced the original small-block Chevy with great enthusiasm as soon as they started turning up in junkyards. Today, purists will howl in outrage about LS-swapped Fox Mustangs, but a dispassionate look at it shows this is the same kind of thing gearheads have always done. Mustang engine transplants aren’t limited to just Chevy engines either – Most famously, the notable 2006 documentary film The Fast and the Furious: Tokyo Drift included a 1967 Ford Mustang Fastback with a Nissan RB26DETT as a ‘hero car.’

Today, purists will howl in outrage about LS-swapped Fox Mustangs, but a dispassionate look at it shows this is the same kind of thing gearheads have always done…

Purple BMW M3 with a RB26DETT Nissan Skyline GT-R Engine
Vehicle: BMW with a Nissan Skyline GT-R RB26DETT Engine
Purple BMW M3 with a RB26DETT Nissan Skyline GT-R Engine
Vehicle: BMW with a Nissan Skyline GT-R RB26DETT Engine

Like Honda swaps, the popularity of the LS Fox combination has led to an entire range of aftermarket parts to make the process close to turn-key, and all the information necessary to make it happen successfully is easily accessible online and in print. In fact, there has been a strong “LS all the things!” movement in the enthusiast world, with practically every rear wheel drive platform becoming a candidate for a Gen III/IV GM V8 swap. It’s even reached the point where a backlash has occurred against it – many people see the commonality of the LS as a detriment to the originality and creativity of Pro Touring builds, preferring original or at least period-correct engines. Odds are that any SEMA resto-mod build that isn’t intended to specifically highlight another engine will have some flavor of LS power, to the point where it’s become a running joke among writers and photographers.

Red nissan 240Z with an LS6 V8 Engine from a corvette
Vehicle: Nissan 240Z with an LS6 Engine from a Corvette

Regardless of one’s feelings about LS engine transplants, they’re going to be with us for the foreseeable future, and not just in cars. They’ve become the weapon of choice for inboard-powered boats of all kinds, as well as aircraft and even homebuilt helicopters. But eventually something new will come along, and it’s entirely possible that we may one day see all-electric powertrains with ‘universal’ designs developed to simply drop in place of an internal combustion engine and transmission. While one-off attempts at this have come and gone, as the hardware becomes standardized for OEM use (and thus also becomes more affordable) and battery technology advances to increase energy density, peak output, and cruising range, garage mechanics who want something completely different under the hood will embrace these swaps as well. 

About the Author: Paul Huizenga is a California-based freelance contributor who has owned, raced, and written about everything from Subarus to Mustangs to Corvettes over the last two decades. He is currently studying the feasibility of an LS4 engine and transmission swap into a Fox-body to convert it to Chevy power and front-wheel drive, because some men just want to watch the world burn.

Chevy LS Engine inside a green restomod 1961 chevy impala bubbletop
Vehicle: ’61 Chevy Impala Bubbletop with an LS V8 Engine
Tires: Milestar MS932XP+ – 245/35R20
Chevy LS Engine inside a green restomod 1961 chevy impala bubbletop
Vehicle: ’61 Chevy Impala Bubbletop with an LS V8 Engine
Tires: Milestar MS932XP+ – 245/35R20
Green Nissan 240SX S14 with a modified Nissan SR-Series Engine
Vehicle: Nissan 240SX S14
Tires: Milestar MS932 Sport – 225/40R18
Green Nissan 240SX S14 with a modified Nissan SR-Series Engine
Vehicle: Nissan 240SX S14
Tires: Milestar MS932 Sport – 225/40R18
Red '68 Chevy El Camino by Hill's Rod Custom with a Supercharged LSA Crate Engine- Streetsteel - 235/60R15
Vehicle: 1968 Chevrolet El Camino with a Supercharged LSA Crate Engine
Tires: Milestar Streetsteel Tires – 235/60R15
Red '68 Chevy El Camino by Hill's Rod Custom with a Supercharged LSA Crate Engine- Streetsteel - 235/60R15
Vehicle: 1968 Chevrolet El Camino with a Supercharged LSA Crate Engine
Tires: Milestar Streetsteel Tires – 235/60R15
Green BMW E30 with an LS V8 Engine
Vehicle: BMW E30 with an LS V8 Engine

The post Hot Swaps appeared first on STATE OF SPEED.

]]>
https://stateofspeed.com/2021/09/29/hot-swaps/feed/ 0
Springs vs. Coilovers vs. Bags: What’s the Difference? https://stateofspeed.com/2021/09/22/springs-vs-coilovers-vs-bags/ https://stateofspeed.com/2021/09/22/springs-vs-coilovers-vs-bags/#respond Wed, 22 Sep 2021 13:05:42 +0000 http://54.201.197.135/?p=27968

Check out the pros and cons of the categories of suspension mods: Spring and damper replacement, coilover conversion, and air suspension.Read More →

The post Springs vs. Coilovers vs. Bags: What’s the Difference? appeared first on STATE OF SPEED.

]]>

Springs vs. Coilovers vs. Bags: What’s the Difference?

Are Springs, Coilovers, or Air Suspension Best for Performance?

It might seem like common sense that having more choices when it comes to just about any decision is a good thing. In many circumstances, that’s true, but when presented with too many options, ‘decision paralysis’ can set in, making it harder instead of easier to choose the right path. Instead of making life easier, it causes anxiety, slows down or even stops decision-making, and can even lead to remorse after the fact as you churn through all the possibilities you didn’t pick. 

Yellow Subaru WRX During a sunset in a city
Vehicle: Subaru WRX

Slammed black lexus and slammed white mustang

Red Toyota AE86 Corolla Levin/ Sprinter Trueno at State of Speed Los Angeles LA car meet
Vehicle: Toyota AE86 Trueno

When it comes to upgrading a car’s suspension for high performance street or track use, we’ve reached the point where for many popular platforms, there’s no clear winner for every situation out of a wide variety of aftermarket setups. While we can’t guarantee you’ll avoid ‘paralysis by analysis,’ we might be able to help clarify your priorities with the following look at the pros and cons of the three basic categories of mods: Spring and damper replacement, coilover conversion, and air suspension. 

Springs and Shocks/Struts

Silver BMW on a road near some mountains
Vehicle: Silver BMW
Tires: Milestar AS710 Sport – 235/50R18

This category encompasses replacing the factory-spec springs and dampers (whether those are conventional shock absorbers, MacPherson struts, or a combination of the two) with upgraded aftermarket parts.  

Blue Mitsubishi Evo near a warehouse
Vehicle: Mitsubishi Evo
Tires: Milestar MS932 Sport – 235/45R17

Pro:

  • Likely to be the least-expensive option, both to buy and to install (if you don’t do it yourself)
  • Properly-engineered matching suspension kits take the guesswork out of picking the right spring rates and compression/rebound settings
  • Durability is often as good as or better than factory parts
  • Some high-end kits offer limited damper adjustment for fine-tuning
  • Fewest compromises in ride quality and noise for dual use street/track cars

Con:

  • Limited range of spring rates for applications ‘out of the mainstream’
  • Systems on the most affordable end of the spectrum usually offer no ride height or damping adjustment
Green 1965 Ford mustang fastback 2+2 on milestar streetsteel tires during a sunset
Vehicle: ’65 Ford Mustang Fastback 2+2
Tires: Milestar Streetsteel Tires – 215/65R15 Front – 215/70R15 Rear

The Bottom Line:

Usually the least-expensive and most-available option, but with significant compromises in adjustability and performance as the tradeoff.

Coilover Conversion

Yellow and blue Bilstein coilovers on a BMW

For the purpose of this discussion, we’re going to define coilovers as a complete replacement of the factory spring and damper setup, whether those are individual components or struts, with aftermarket alternatives. This is the most typical choice for serious track applications, but also has a wide fanbase for street/track use as well – partially because of the serious race cred and the ‘hardcore’ aura that goes with the tradeoffs involved. 

modified Red Mitsubishi Evo on Milestar MS932 XP+ Tires with a rustic background during a sunset
Vehicle: Mitsubishi Evo
Tires: Milestar MS932 XP+ – 265/35ZR18

Pro: 

  • Short of a completely re-engineered suspension right down to the control arms and chassis attachment points, coilovers offer the best possible handling and the widest range of adjustment, as well as more precision and repeatability when changing settings
  • Good coverage from multiple manufacturers for the most popular car applications
  • Narrower coilover units can offer more clearance for wider wheels and tires without fender modification
  • Adjustable ride height without altering spring rates
  • Dampers available in configurations from non-adjustable to 4-way (high/low speed compression and rebound)
  • Relatively simple and easy to change spring rates with ‘universal’ springs to suit different track conditions

Con: 

  • A very, very wide range of quality/price, from pro level down to “I bought this off of Wish – why doesn’t it fit?”
  • A whole new form of decision paralysis – lots of adjustment often means more ways to get it wrong
  • Systems intended for track use can be noisy and harsh on less-than-perfect pavement
  • Expect to either replace or rebuild the dampers on a regular basis, as they are usually designed with longevity as a lower priority
  • Less-common performance cars may need to have coilover sets pieced together from components if ‘all in one box’ kits aren’t available
Grey Chevrolet Camaro Sang near some ship docks on a cloudy day
Vehicle: Chevrolet Camaro
Tires: Milestar MS932XP+ – 275/40ZR20

The Bottom Line:

Not the best choice for comfort or street driving, but the de-facto standard for full-race use. Beware of pitfalls in quality at the low end of the scale, and excessive complexity at the high end.

Air Suspension

Close up of the bags on an Air Suspension system in a orange '69 Chevrolet Camaro Muscle car
Vehicle: 1969 Chevrolet Camaro
Tires: Milestar Streetsteel Tires – 215/65R15 Front – 245/60R15 Rear

Commonly referred to as “bags,” today’s performance-oriented air suspension systems are a far cry from the lashed-together rigs that pioneered the technology. Once strictly an option for “stance” and car shows instead of performance, it’s now a solid contender for track-oriented builds.

Close up of the bags on an Air Suspension system in a orange '69 Chevrolet Camaro Muscle car
Vehicle: 1969 Chevrolet Camaro
Tires: Milestar Streetsteel Tires – 215/65R15 Front – 245/60R15 Rear

Pro:

  • Adjustable ride height is the main attraction here – modern air springs offer a wide range of spring heights selectable simply by adding or reducing pressure, and clever design of the air bags themselves achieves this without significant changes in spring rate
  • Compatible with multi-adjustable race-spec dampers for suspension tuning
  • Systems with quality air springs rival conventional factory steel springs for durability
  • A great choice for cars that will see use on both the race course and the street, making low ride height that would be a disaster with a ‘static’ coilover suspension achievable in a car you can still drive to and from the track
  • Complete, ready-to-install kits are available for more applications every day

Con: 

  • Trends towards the expensive end of the scale compared to anything but full-race coilover systems
  • Additional hardware like compressors, tanks, solenoids, and pressure gauges required for adjustment on-the-fly, which adds expense and weight
  • Modern air springs only allow changes in ride height while spring rate remains the same, requiring complete replacement of a relatively expensive component to alter it
  • Like coilovers, less-popular applications may require ‘a la carte’ component selection instead of an off-the-shelf solution
Dark Grey Lexus RC-F with a red brick background
Vehicle: Lexus RC-F
Tires: Milestar MS932XP+ – 275/30ZR20

The Bottom Line:
The king of adjustability, at the expense of additional weight and cost. Limited (but growing) off-the-shelf choices.

Wrapping it Up

White Mazda RX-7 Gen 2 at State Of Speed Los Angeles LA car meet
Vehicle: Mazda RX-7 Gen 2
slammed and bagged Yellow Honda S2000 with an air suspension system at a car show
Vehicle: Honda S2000
Orange 1960's BMW 2002 in front of a store at a car meet during an overcast day
Vehicle: 60’s BMW 2002
slammed with an air bag system Pink BMW 8-series e31 at an outdoor car show
Vehicle: BMW 8-Series (E31)

There’s no one-size-fits all solution to picking the right path for the suspension on your project car or daily driver, and the wide variety of choices (made worse by conflicting advice from all directions) doesn’t help. Hopefully we’ve made it a little bit easier for you to organize your priorities, from the cost involved to the complexity of installation and tuning to your personal intended use (which often turns out to be somewhat different from where you actually end up in practice). Relax, take a deep breath, and consider the options we have set before you as a starting point in your search for the perfect suspension.

 

 

 

 

The post Springs vs. Coilovers vs. Bags: What’s the Difference? appeared first on STATE OF SPEED.

]]>
https://stateofspeed.com/2021/09/22/springs-vs-coilovers-vs-bags/feed/ 0